The Family

The Season 1 finale revealed that Adam Warren — the presumed-dead teen at the center of the saga — was actually alive, and he intended to reclaim his life from Ben, the impostor who’d moved in with his family. Ahead of the show’s cancellation, series creator Jenna Bans told TVLine, “It won’t be late into [Season 2] that [Adam] makes his reappearance into the family… It will be in the first two minutes.” Bans confirmed it was “always part of the pitch” to bring Adam back, and Season 2 would have focused on him and Ben “circling each other” as they attempt to lead normal lives. Elsewhere, Season 2 would have zeroed in on the murder of journalist Bridey Cruz, who was set to appear in flashbacks even after her death. “[That murder] heavily implicated [Alison Pill’s] Willa,” Bans hinted. “You’ll see in Season 2 that the answer isn’t so clear-cut.”