ABC Family

When Season 1 wrapped up, Walter caught Kat and Patrick in bed, Bianca saw Joey kiss someone else, and Chastity transferred schools. What was on deck for Round 2? Patrick and Kat’s relationship would’ve grown stronger, with Walt becoming a father figure to Patrick; a Bianca/Cameron/Joey love triangle would have emerged, sparking waves of mixed feelings and drama; and Chastity would not have returned to Padua, series creator Carter Covington told EW. Oh, and Blank?

The teen drama “ended” with Amy calling off her wedding, leaving Ricky and John for New York, while Jack and Grace decided to be (gasp!) just friends. So, what would’ve happened next?

Chloe King’s run was cut far too short, leaving many viewers dying to know what happened to the girl with ancient, cat-like powers. When we last saw her, Chloe gave Brian a potentially fatal kiss, while Zane launched an all-out assault on Jasmine and Valentina.

When we last left Kyle, he learned that Cassidy was his brother and that Latnok was trying to clone him.

Jane spent Season 1 lying about her age in order to work as the assistant to a big-time fashion exec, but in the finale, her cover was potentially blown when her boss (Andie MacDowell) caught her sewing costumes for her high school’s musical. Would the fashion newbie have gotten snipped come Season 2? No, series creator April Blair tells Hollywood Life. Rather, Eli would’ve helped Jane keep her secret on the down low.

This criminally underrated drama ended with cancer patient April (played by Italia Ricci) opting to live out her remaining days in Italy, a decision that would have gone very differently had the show received a third season. First of all, April “would get back to Boston and go through with the transplant,” executive producer Patrick Sean Smith told TVLine. “We’d probably have to do a time jump from that, and we would see that it’s successful.” The show would have explored the “complexities” of April and Dominic’s relationship, with the two ultimately ending as close friends.

Though the ballet-centric series was axed before co-creator Amy Sherman-Palladino could draw up many plans for the future, she and stars Sutton Foster, Kelly Bishop and Stacey Oristano told a crowd at the 2015 ATX Festival how they hoped life in Paradise, Calif., would have gone on. To wit: Michelle would’ve stayed in town (but might have started a new, serious relationship), Fanny would run her dance studio until the bitter end, and Truly was on track to Scotty. “She had such a crush!” Oristano cried.